# A Teacher looks at Advent of Code 2020 - Days 7 and 8

Today we'll talk about days seven and eight.

Let's start with 7. I teach all morning on Mondays. I woke up and worked out and then took a look at the problem in the few minutes before class. It was certainly harder than days one through six but I felt it was something I knew I could do based on past experience so I quickly started to throw something together. I tried to finish it in the between classes but couldn't get the right answer to part one. After class I spent more time debugging. I was pretty certain my algorithm was right and it turns out it was. The problem was in my parsing.

Anyway, to the problem. Read it over if you haven't yet.

If you've studied data structures and algorithms you'll recognize that this problem can be viewed as a graph problem. Bags are nodes in the graph and edges tell you what bags each bag can contain.

The data is set up to represent a graph like this:

I left out the weights (numbers of bags). This can be represented in an adjacency list. The video does this in Clojure but in Python, you'd get something that starts like this:

``````{'lightred'     : ['brightwhite', 'mutedyellow'],
'darkorange'   : ['brightwhite','mutedyellow'],
'brightwhite'  : ['shinygold'],
'shinygold'    :['darkolive','vibrantplum'],

The challenge comes when you see that many starting points can lead to the goal of the shiny gold bag.

The insight comes when you notice that you can "reverse the edges." For example, when we saw the line that led to the lightred contains brightwhite and mutedyellow, instead we represent it the other way making two entries - brightwhite is contained by lightred and also mutedyellow is contained by lightred.

Once we set this up the solution is a breadth or depth first search.

The video doesn't do a complet walk through but goes into more details.

I like this type of problem for classes because students can see that sometimes changing the data can make the problem much easier. If you implement the adjacency list as it's presented the problem seems hard. Once you see you can go from shinygold out instead of from all the bags to shinygold the porblem becomes much easier.

The other interesting point is that without fundamental data structures and algorithms this is a hard problem. With them, it's pretty straightforward. Remind your students of this when they ask why they need data structures and algorithms. This problem might be made up but graphs represent a lot of things in the real world and graph traversals and algorithms can solve a lot of real world problems

Now to day 8.

Day 8 involved a simple machine simulator and leads to a very straightforward solution - write a program that simulates the computer stated in the problem. My solution tries to approach the problem in a functional way and also makes use of a function lookup table to avoid multiple ifs. The solution and complete walk through is in the video and in Clojure but a similar solution can be written in Python.