I primarily program in four languages these days -
And most of the time, my Emacs configuration has handled each one differently. Cider for Clojure, Irony for C++, Elpy and Jedi for Python and Java I could never figure out. This is of course on top of tools that work across languages like company for completions, or flycheck for general language syntax checking.
A while ago I heard about lsp-mode - Language Server Protocol mode. Basically, you set up the mode and it connects to back end language servers. The idea is to keep configuration down and provide a consistent interface across langauges while leveraging the types of support these back ends can provide. I wrote a bit about lsp-mode and made a video and you can find it here.
When I first tried LSP it just didn't work. I tried it again later and it basically worked but was finicky. Configuration took more work than I wanted, particularly for customizing per language and even when working it didn't work as expected.
This past summer, I had to teach using Java so I tried lsp-mode again. Setup wasn't too bad and most of the issues were more related to Java than to lsp-mode but I didn't like the results. While it might be great for the professional developer there were too many popups and made the screen way too busy for teaching.
Still, the idea of a single simple configuration was enticing.
So, when I decided to get my configuration together for the Fall semester I decided to try yet again and discovered eglot for Emacs. Eglot turned out to be easier to install and gave me more of the experience I was looking for.
To start, I set it up for C++ using
(use-package eglot :ensure t) (add-to-list 'eglot-server-programs '((c++-mode c-mode) "clangd-10")) (add-hook 'c-mode-hook 'eglot-ensure) (add-hook 'c++-mode-hook 'eglot-ensure)
Eglot defaults to ccls as a C++ language server. I didn't want to have
to build it but was able to
apt-get install clangd-10 and use that
instead by adding clangd-10 to the eglot-server-programs in the second
For python I had to install pyls, the Python Language Server but that
was easy to do and then I just had to add
'eglot-ensure) to my config.
Finally, Java was more of an issue I had to get eclipse.jdt.ls on my system. It turns out that lsp-mode installed it for me already so I just had to point to it:
(defconst my-eclipse-jdt-home "/home/zamansky/.emacs.d/.cache/lsp/eclipse.jdt.ls/plugins/org.eclipse.equinox.launcher_1.5.800.v20200727-1323.jar") (defun my-eglot-eclipse-jdt-contact (interactive) "Contact with the jdt server input INTERACTIVE." (let ((cp (getenv "CLASSPATH"))) (setenv "CLASSPATH" (concat cp ":" my-eclipse-jdt-home)) (unwind-protect (eglot--eclipse-jdt-contact nil) (setenv "CLASSPATH" cp)))) (setcdr (assq 'java-mode eglot-server-programs) #'my-eglot-eclipse-jdt-contact) (add-hook 'java-mode-hook 'eglot-ensure)
So far, I'm liking eglot very much. I'll probably check lsp-mode out again somewhere down the line but as of now it's Cider for Clojure and Eglot for everything else.
The video has a run through and demo. Check it out.